Too Darn Hot: A Classic Song Served 6 Different Ways

Jul 06, 2014 | 1:33 PM

I’ve started to put together the set list for my next live show (which, incidentally, is August 15th at The Stephen Talkhouse in Amagansett and you can get your tickets here:



“I hope you’re going to include some classics,” my father said when I told him, during one of our early morning phone chats recently, that I want to shake things up a bit this summer.


“Of course I’ll include some classics!” I said. “That’s what I do!”


“Yes,” he said, “but let’s face it. One person’s classic is not necessarily another’s. I don’t mean that stuff that’s on the Classic Rock channel, or the Lithium station. I mean American Songbook classics.”



“Oh, daddy,” I chastised, “I know the difference between an American Songbook classic and everything else.”


But as soon as I hung up the phone I began to ponder: just what does makes one song a card holding member of The American Songbook, and another not? Is it the year it was written? Is it the lyric? Or the melody?


There is, of course, a general consensus that The American Songbook does, in fact, refer to the popular songs written for Broadway and film between the 1920 and the 1950s (give or take a few years). But this narrow definition leaves out some of the great songs that have been written since.


The criteria, therefore (for me, anyway) seems less to do with a date in history, and more to do with the ability of a particular song to be reinterpreted again and again over the years and still feel timely. Or perhaps a better way to say it is, an American Songbook classic has a time – less quality that makes the song endure through the ages like a novel by Jane Austen or a black dress by Coco Channel.



How many artists have covered tunes by Irving Berlin? Johnny Mercer? Cole Porter? The Gershwins? Rodgers and Hart? Rodgers and Hammerstein? Lerner and Loewe? Comden and Greene and Bernstein?



The answer is countless, and that’s because those songs are structurally so good– meaning the lyrics and melodies and the way they are put together– that they have been covered countless times by countless artist.


Just to give you an example of how a classic can be interpreted, I found six different versions of Cole Porter’s “Too Darn Hot,” written, originally, for the show Kiss Me Kate.


ANN MILLER in the original movie version:






Which one is your favorite? Please let me know!


xo as always,





2 thoughts on “Too Darn Hot: A Classic Song Served 6 Different Ways”

  1. Jan     Reply

    Great selection Isabel – great song.
    Will be in my head all day now though.
    Not that that’s a bad thing!

  2. Diamond Dahl     Reply

    I’m always going to be partial to the original, but that may be a fondness for the costume, and awe of her dancing!

    I particularly enjoyed Anthony Strong, his voice reminds me of Harry Connick, Jr., one of my faves. I don’t care much for remixes, so the modified Ella I didn’t even let play though. Erasure was different though, and a new listen for me!

Leave a Comment